When you are out to get a crib for your baby, you should also buy a crib mattress. After all, it is the crib mattress that will make your baby’s bedding highly comfortable for them. You can see how your baby will feel all happy and chirpy after a good sleep. That is undoubtedly not something that you will get to see in a baby that did not have the right sleeping environment. Sleep is known to be very crucial for your baby’s growth as their body grows every day; they need to have the right amount of rest, which is consistent and comfortable.

A baby crib mattress is a smaller sized mattress with less thickness. However, it is designed to help your baby drift off to sleep and slip into those lovely dreams. The mattress fills the crib and contours according to your child’s body’s shape to let them feel relaxed whenever they want to rest. We get to see parents thinking a lot while picking the right crib mattress. They should surely think a lot as the mattress becomes an essential part of the crib and is used every day for a long time.

Best Buy Baby Crib Mattress Reviews

However, the crib mattress you get to have from the local market is unknown to that qualitative. Their foam is comparatively less comfortable than the crib mattresses manufactured by well-known brands. Therefore, we have for you the ten best quality crib mattresses today. We have done a fair amount of study on each of the picks and tried to review them for you. We have also mentioned what we did not come to like about each crib mattress. You will get all the details on the best rated crib mattresses that we have selected.

Let us know about them below –

1. Graco Premium Foam Toddler Crib Mattress

Graco Premium Foam Toddler Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

The Graco Toddler Crib Mattress is very well rated for its soft foam and water-resistant nature. It has also got a cover made out of polyester. Often, when your baby has a diaper rash, you will let him or her sleep without wearing the diaper. That can lead to leakage on the crib. Local crib mattresses might go bad even after being exposed to that kind of leakage, not a lot of times. However, the Graco Premium Toddler mattress will not ever disappoint you when it comes to that.

Additionally, the foam used in the product is so breathable that your little one will never feel any discomfort while sleeping on it. It is known to maximize the airflow in it very much. Other than that, Graco also focuses a lot on making its products the safest. Because of it, this crib mattress is very well tested and is known to be free from all the prohibited phthalates, mercury, lead, etc. it also meets all the standards set by CPSC and ATSM International.

What we liked:

  • You will get a 6-year warranty on this crib mattress by Graco.
  • It has got the softest touch to it and a very breathable foamy structure.
  • It will fit any full-sized baby crib easily.
  • The foam used in the product is the polyurethane foam, and the overall structure of the mattress will remain intact.
  • The cover of the mattress makes it resistant to any leakage.

What we didn’t like:

  • We like all the things about the Graco Premium Foam Crib Mattress.

2. Dream on Me Gold Certified Waterproof Crib Mattress

Dream on Me Gold Certified Waterproof Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

We now have the Dream on Me Waterproof Crib Mattress with us. You must have heard about and tried a lot of crib mattress on your baby’s crib. But you will still find this particular crib mattress to be highly unique in every way. It has got a hypoallergenic surface, which is very suitable for babies as their skin is a lot more sensitive than older children and adults. Extra precautions will only help your baby have the best time and get satisfactory and long sleep every day without trouble.

We also happen to really like the anti-bacterial cover on this crib mattress, which is also waterproof. Thus, not only does the mattress prevent harm to the mattress’s life from leakage, but it also helps prevent the growth of mildew and mold on it.  Other than that, it also keeps the mattress’s odor at bay even after long years of its usage. However, wiping crib mattresses clean is still essential. For that, in this crib mattress, you can use some wipes dipped in warm water. One can also incorporate the use of a mild soap while being at it.

What we liked:

  • The comfort that the Dream on Me crib mattress offers is genuinely exceptional.
  • It is available in a plain white as well as a printed design.
  • This crib mattress is 3 inches thick and has got the dimensions of 38 X 24 X 3 inches.
  • Its cover is waterproof, hypoallergenic as well as anti-bacterial.
  • It has no lead and phthalates in its material.

What we didn’t like:

  • We have nothing to mention here till now.

3. Newton Baby Crib Mattress with Removable Cover Included

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

There is nothing better than the Newton Baby Crib Mattress. It is known for its soft design and ability to fit in all types of cribs. It will offer the best thickness so that your baby can rest well on it every day. As far as its foam is concerned, you must know that it is very soft. No matter which position your baby sleeps in, the foam will help them adjust their bodies in the best way without any discomfort. One can also count on such mattresses and use them for years to come on their baby’s crib.

Additionally, the mattress also offers a more extended life. With a crib mattress that you might find in the market, you will have to compromise on one thing or another. However, with the Newton Baby Mattress, you won’t have to compromise even on the littlest things. It will help save you from all the hassle that the previous crib mattress of yours might have caused you. Furthermore, you can also find its cover fitting to other crib mattresses that you might own. It is fully removable, easy to wash, and waterproof.

What we liked:

  • The crib mattress is built in such a way that it will help adjust your baby his/her position throughout the night.
  • You can buy its cover in different colors and attractive design options.
  • The covers could also fit other crib mattresses quite easily.
  • It does not weight that much and will fit perfectly well.

What we didn’t like:

  • For smaller cribs, this crib mattress won’t fit that easily.

4. My First Mattress Crib Mattress with Waterproof Cover

My First Mattress Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

It is vital to have crib mattresses with a waterproof cover these days that we cannot even fathom explaining its idea. Mattresses tend to lose their structure. Their foam might also go bad after having to bear leakage again and again. With many parents choosing cloth diapers these days, it is undoubtedly tough to stop the leakage from entering the mattress. However, a waterproof cover will always keep the leakage away and help you enjoy having the mattress for a very long time. For long term usage, mattresses like that are loved a lot.

For all those reasons, we have the MY First Mattress Crib Mattress with us. Its foam is unique and made using the premium polyurethane mattress foam, which is also Certi-PUR-US certified. It is quite flexible and fit your baby’s or toddlers crib very well. It is safe and free from lead, mercury, phthalates, and all those harmful chemicals are known to flare up skin reactions on babies’ sensitive skin. Other than that, this crib mattress also keeps mites away. As the foam used in it is also the memory foam, it will never make noises as your baby moved on it while sleeping. Get this crib mattress now!

What we liked:

  • It has got a very soft velour cover which is removable and waterproof.
  • It can easily fit many Premium and well-known brand cribs.
  • This crib mattress is also mite proof and anti-microbial.
  • It will never cause any allergic reaction to your baby’s skin.
  • As its foam is certified by CertiPUR-US, you can be sure of the product being free from flame retardants, formaldehyde, and other chemicals.

What we didn’t like:

  • The mattress maybe a little smaller around the edges for some standard size cribs.

5. Milliard Baby Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress with a Waterproof Cover

Milliard Baby Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

The Milliard Baby Crib Mattress has single-handedly won the hearts of many parents across the USA. While most baby crib mattresses come with a plain and bland cover, the Milliard baby mattress has a dotted cover with a gray-based colored design. It is known to be 100% waterproof. This feature of the mattress has also been tested many times, and the product has never failed. Other than that, the mattress has passed all the Federal Anti-inflammability requirements apart from being free from all chemicals and toxins.

We like how it supersedes all the local crib mattresses and never goes out of shape. This is the courtesy of its high-density foam, which not only keeps the foam intact but also helps it remain soft for your baby’s maximum comfort. The dimensions of this crib mattress are 52 X 27.5 X 4.75 inches. It will fit standard sized cribs and help promote good and restful sleep for your baby every day. Furthermore, its foam is known to well contour to your baby’s body shape so that it helps relieve all the fatigue that they might feel after playing all day long.

What we liked:

  • As the mattress promotes airflow, it helps regulate your baby’s sleep temperature.
  • The mattress’s natural shape contours well to your baby’s body and helps them feel highly relaxed.
  • It has got a printed cover which is also waterproof.
  • Its dimensions are 31.5 X 9 X 9.3 inches.

What we didn’t like:

  • Some people may not happen to like the printer cover and want the plain design.

6. LA Baby Waterproof and Portable Mini Crib Mattress

LA Baby Waterproof and Portable Mini Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

The LA Baby Mini Mattress for Baby Cribs has been around for quite some time. When most crib mattresses are made for standard crib sizes, this mattress will suit your requirements if you have got a crib that is not that large. This way, you will get to use a mattress that will fit perfectly inside your baby’s crib without creating all those unwanted problems. Its cover is triple laminated and will never shred even after using it for a very long time. It is the quality of the crib mattress that matters a whole lot, after all.

With the LA Baby Mini Crib Mattress, your baby will get the best sleep for the perfect duration. Babies seem happier and relaxed when they get the right to sleep every night. For that, having the right crib mattress matters more than anything else. Besides being one of the highest comfort-offering mattresses, this mattress also has a cover, which is genuinely hypoallergenic and easy to clean. It is exclusively made perfectly in the USA and weighs only 4 pounds. Because of such lightweight, you get to move it quickly without finding it to be too heavy. You must try the LA Baby Mini Crib Mattress for sure.

What we liked:

  • The triple laminated cover of this crib mattress will always remain tear-resistant.
  • The same cover is also hypoallergenic and nontoxic.
  • The foam of this mattress is of the perfect density and is very comfortable.
  • The mattress is made out of flame-retardant material and will fit mini cribs perfectly.
  • It also comes with a warranty that is a year long.

What we didn’t like:

  • For more oversized cribs, this is not the crib mattress that will suffice the needs.

7. Sealy Waterproof Standard Toddler & Crib Mattress

Sealy Waterproof Standard Toddler & Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

You can get the Sealy Waterproof crib mattress in different finishes. These finishes include the Baroque, Cotton Comfort, and Brushed zip knit finishes. However, the baroque version will cost comparatively lesser and the cotton comfort version a bit more. Sealy crib mattresses are sold in America a lot because their mattress is parent trusted and high on safety and quality offerings. When you get a Sealy Mattress for your baby’s crib, you can be sure about the highest level of comfort it will offer every night to your baby. Not only that, but their mattresses also have well-defined edges, which make the entire looks simply perfect.

Apart from that, they are always determined to offer the safest sleeping environment to your baby. This can be why their mattresses are the ones that pass the GREENGUARD’s Gold Standards. Furthermore, the Sealy Waterproof crib mattress also holds the CertiPUR-US certificates to ensure that it is made using the safest techniques. It will prevent the growth of mildew on it very well. The foam of the mattress is wholly nontoxic and offers a waterproof barrier for a longer lifespan. The best can be made to come out of this crib mattress if it fits perfectly in the crib that you have in your home for your baby or toddler.

What we liked:

  • You will get the Sealy crib mattress in an easy-to-carry box.
  • The leaky messes will never reach the mattress’s foam as it has a waterproof cover on it.
  • The foam of the mattress is nontoxic and supportive.
  • You can choose this mattress from three different finished version.
  • Its edges are so well defined that the mattress looks perfect.

What we didn’t like:

  • The Cotton Comfort version of the crib mattress costs more than the others.

8. Clevr Crib Mattress with Memory Foam

Clevr Crib Mattress with Memory Foam

Buy Now at Amazon

When mattresses are made using the memory foam, they turn out to be genuinely fantastic. They help a lot as they are hugely comfortable. However, the best thing about such foams is that they never create unwanted sounds when moving on them. A baby’s ears can catch even the littlest noises, which can hinder their sleep and easily disrupt their sleep patterns. However, with the Clevr Crib Mattress, you will see how even when your baby moves, the mattress will never make even a single bit of sound at all. Its foam construction is also unique and is known to be very qualitative.

The memory foam used in this crib mattress is placed right on top of the polyurethane foam. Because of this structure, the mattress gets the perfect structure yet remains very soft and highly comfortable. The material of the mattress is free from all known heavy metals and is also CertiPUR-US certified. With that, you must deduce its overall high quality. The Clevr crib mattress also comes with a bamboo cover, which adds to the overall softness and also feels very natural. It has also got a dotted finish at the bottom, which helps it to not slip from where it is. It is indeed one of the best crib mattresses ever manufactured.

Things we liked:

  • This mattress is known to support the growth of your baby’s bones.
  • The dimensions are 52 X 27.5 X 5 inches.
  • The Bamboo fabric cover on the mattress adds softness to this crib mattress.
  • The foam of the mattress using both the memory foam and polyurethane foam.
  • It also has a CertiPUR-US certificate.

Things we didn’t like:

  • The price of this crib mattress is quite high.

9. Bubble Bear Infant and Toddler Crib Mattress

Bubble Bear Infant and Toddler Crib Mattress

Buy Now at Amazon

We have now finally come to the Bubble Bear Infant Toddler Mattress. While we were picking from many baby crib mattresses, we came across many high-end options that had a lot of features; however, they still lacked in some factor or the other even after being so pricey. However, when we found the Bubble Bear Crib mattress, we could surely not find such missing factors and facets. Even after having a rate that is close to the average price of Premium and qualitative crib mattresses, this mattress is still so amazing and has got all the features that are essential in the right crib mattress.

You can also choose it from many printed designs. Our favorite is the Jewelry Blue design, which looks so unique and adorable altogether. Bubble Bear got established in 2000 and since then has pledged to make only the best baby products with a safe and comfortable design. This baby crib mattress by them has got materials used in it, which are entirely non-toxic and also be free from chemicals that cause skin reactions in babies. Additionally, this crib mattress is popular because it does not lose its shape remains firm other than offering maximized airflow. You will like this crib mattress a whole lot. It is free from latex and has got the dimensions of 30 X 7.6 X 7.3 inches.

What we liked:

  • You can get the Bubble Bear crib mattress from different printed designs.
  • It is truly hypoallergenic and free from all sorts of chemicals that harm the skin.
  • The border wires design helps the mattress to never lose its shape.
  • Its foams firmness is also perfect and comfortable.

What we didn’t like:

  • Many people like plain designs of mattresses. So they might not like this one.

How to Choose the Right Crib Mattress

We have chosen the following facets and factors of a crib mattress that you must indeed think of and consider while you are thinking of purchasing one. All the crucial details are given below –

1. Crib Mattress’s Foam Type

Most crib mattresses are made out of foams that are soft, but they lose shape after a while. Also, if you choose a local crib mattress, you will see how its foam will start clumping only after a year of usage. Therefore, the mattress that you consider for your baby’s crib should not only be comfortable but also have the features of shape and size retention. You can also check if the crib mattress has both polyurethane and memory foams in its design, as those ones make it quite perfect.

2. Size of the crib mattress

Nothing is as basic of a factor that the size of the mattress for a consideration. However, we still want to really focus on that. Most people get carried away with the astonishing features of the mattress and then get disappointed as it does not fit their baby’s crib. Therefore, knowing the dimensions of your baby’s crib is very important. You can match those dimensions with that of the crib and get a crib mattress, which will not leave empty spaces around it and stick to fitting perfectly inside the crib. The dimensions of the crib mattress can be easily known from its details.

3. Cover of the mattress crib

Most parents pick mattresses for their babies crib, which come with a waterproof cover. These covers do not let the leakage enter the foam and slowly make it go bad. Instead, they keep the moisture right on top and enhance the life of that crib mattress. You can also go with natural covers, which are usually made out of cotton or bamboo fabric, as they are known to be quite soft. They never cause any harsh scratches on your baby’s body and make them feel the most comfortable while the babies try sleeping for long hours. You can get both these types of crib mattresses in our picks.

4. Safety Features of the Crib Mattress

Mattresses that hold the CertiPUR-US certificate are the ones that are made in the safest ways possible. They do not have a material with harsh chemicals and are known to be safe for babies at all times. These days finding such crib mattresses is quite easy. Chemicals like phthalates and formaldehyde are known to be quite harmful so try to avoid them while buying a crib mattress. Other than that, you should also never buy crib mattresses that are known to have a flammable nature. You should surely keep the safety of your child as your number one priority.

5. Quality and Price of the Crib Mattress

The quality of a crib mattress reflects the number of people buying it. Those people also try to drop their genuine and honest mattress reviews under the product. Try going through them when you are willing to buy a particular crib mattress. We have chosen only the best crib mattresses, but this will surely be immensely helpful when you are choosing a crib mattress from somewhere else. Other than that, the crib mattress’s price also needs consideration. Higher priced crib mattress won’t ensure the highest quality, so stick to the ones that fit the criteria and are well-loved by customers all over.

How To Care For Baby Crib Mattresses?

When you are having the right crib mattress for your baby, you will be able to allow your baby to sleep peacefully. You will also be able to avoid any kind of accidents, inhaling chemicals and also getting tangled. The crib mattress when chosen right will offer the baby enough rest and also make sure that the bone development is good for the baby. So, here are some tips that can help you with taking care of the baby crib mattresses:

  • Airing out the mattress is one of the most important thing to keep in mind. When the mattress first arrives, you will have to unpack the mattress and leave it in air for at least two days. Any uncommon smell or scent that you can find in a new mattress will fade off when you leave it in air for two days. Any unwanted toxins in the mattress will also fade off when you leave it in open air.
  • When there is any spill or accident, you will have to make sure that you are cleaning it off immediately. As it is a baby crib mattress, accidents and spills are very common. If you don’t clean them immediately, then they can turn into hygiene issues. Along with that, they can also turn into bacteria or mold formation. So, you should always make sure that you are cleaning it off immediately. For that you need to follow all the instructions that are given by the manufacturer.
  • The best way to care for the baby crib mattress is by using a mattress cover. It is good to get a waterproof mattress cover. That will protect the mattress and also it is very easy for you to clean the cover rather than protecting the crib mattress from spills.
  • Build up of dust and dirt is very common in any area of the room. It will be the same with the baby crib mattress as well. So, you need to make sure that you are cleaning it up from time to time. At least once in a week, you will have to clean the crib mattress with the help of the vacuum cleaner. That will help in reducing any kind of dust and dirt that can get accumulated. This is a very useful tip for the baby’s health as well
  • You should also make sure that you are rotating the crib mattress regularly. If you are using it just from one side, there are chances that it shrinks from one side. That can make the mattress look old and odd. So, if you keep rotating it from time to time, then you will be able to maintain the shape of the mattress.
  • Not just at the beginning of usage, but even in the middle, you will have to leave the mattress outside under the sun for air drying. That will help in keeping the mattress clean and dry all the You will also be able to avoid any bad smell.

Here are some of the frequently asked questions for crib mattresses. Go ahead and check out the details now.

Baby Crib Mattress Frequently Asked Questions

There is a problem associated with the soft crib mattress. The baby can suffocate if he falls with the head first on the mattress. This is a leading cause of sudden infant death syndrome in babies of up to 1 year in age. In addition to this, the soft mattresses can lead to deformation in babies as the babies have close to 300 bones. The firm mattress supports the baby’s skeleton, and it helps in the rapid development of the baby as well. You can go ahead and buy a firm mattress instead of the soft mattress for the safety and development of the baby.
The baby is going to urinate while sleeping, and you can’t just avoid that. However, you can stop the mattress from getting wet with the help of a mattress liner or a waterproof cover. These are easily available in the market, and you can use them to keep the mattress dry. This will eliminate the need to clean the mattress and drying it every day. Wet mattresses can also be a breeding ground for bacteria so that you can avoid all these things with the crib mattress protector’s help. They are available at an affordable price.
You might be able to find the crib mattress made of memory foam, but you should never use it for your baby. The mattress made of memory foam is very dangerous, and it can lead to suffocation since the material is very soft. The problem associated with the memory foam mattress is the same as the soft mattress, and for the same matter, you should not use it. Many of you might believe that the memory foam or soft foam would make the baby comfortable, but in reality, it would do more harm than good. So, you can use the regular firm crib mattresses.
A lot of companies came up with an innovative mattress which is called Breathable Crib Mattress. These mattresses are made so that the baby can breathe even if he is sleeping with the face down. Using the breathable crib mattress will ensure that the baby doesn’t suffocate to death. Using the breathable crib mattress is certainly makes a lot of sense. You can choose a combination of organic and breathable mattresses. The advantage of the organic mattress would be that the mattress would not emit toxic gases, which in return will make the mattress safe for you.
The cribs have a standard size on them. Similarly, the mattresses also have a standard size. You need to match the two to get the right crib mattress. Do not buy smaller mattresses as it can be a possible pinch point. Do not buy oversized crib mattresses since they can be challenging to fit. The right approach would be to opt for the exact size of the mattress.

Bottom Line

One has to be quite picky when getting the chance to choose the right baby crib mattress. After all, that is how someone is while choosing a product for their babies. After all, we also want your baby to have the best products ever. We spent efforts and a lot of time reading as well as studying all the features of crib mattresses and got to choose the ones that fit the perfect criteria. You can browse through all our picks and get the right crib mattress for your baby now!