Manual Breast Pump Vs. Electric Breast Pump: Which is Better?

A newborn baby needs breast milk as part of their nourishment. Breast milk is a complete meal for a baby and every baby feeds on it till they reach the age of a toddler. Breastfeeding a baby is a wonderful experience for a mother and is often cited as a bonding session for both. However, in the modern-day era, where mothers are equally participating in working roles, breastfeeding can become a tedious task. Many mothers are tasked with returning to the office pretty soon after giving birth.

This is where a breast pump can come in handy. With the help of a breast pump, a mother can express their milk and store it for further use. That milk can then be fed to the baby later on. This way a mom can manage their work-life all the while making sure their baby gets the right nourishment in the form of breast milk.

There are two types of breast pumps available in the market in the form of an electric breast pump and a manual breast pump. We’ve detailed both of them in our previous blog and now look to compare them down over here to find out which is better. Let’s check out.

Manual Breast PumpElectric Breast Pump
# Haakaa Manual Breast Pump# Medela Electric Breast Pump
Haakaa Manual Breast PumpMedela Electric Breast Pump
Buy Now at AmazonBuy Now at Amazon

But first, a few things that you should know about using a breast pump.

Things to know while using a breast pump

As we know that there are two types of breast pumps in the market one is an electric breast pump, and another is manual breast pump. The electric one works with the help of mains operated power or battery power while the manual one works via a handheld lever. Both of these come with a suction cup that should be placed on the breast. This then creates a suction for the milk to be expressed. For the manual breast pump, the hand lever works to pump the milk while for the electric one, the motor works to pump the milk. Both of these come with a storage bottle where the milk is stored.

But before you use a breast pump you should clean the area around the breast and also sterilize the breast pump so that the baby doesn’t get allergens. Furthermore, you should also store the milk in a refrigerator so that it stays fresh.

Manual Breast Pump Vs Electric Breast Pump: Which is better?

manual vs electric breast pump

Here, we look at the different parameters and compare both of these breast pumps to find out which is better. Read along.

How often do you pump?

  • One of the first and foremost things to know before opting fora breast pump is how often do you want to express the breast milk. For say, if you don’t find any issue with breastfeeding and only need a breast pump once or twice a month, then a manual breast pump will do fine. But if you need to express the milk regularly then going for an electric one should be your top priority.

Ease of use

  • When we talk of ease of use, there are two different things to look at. If you take a look at the electric ones, they work much efficiently than the manual breast pump. With the electric pump, you can place it as required, i.e. put the suction cup on the breast and switch on the machine. The milk will be expressed. But with the manual one, you can to continuously use a lever to pump the milk. But if you look it based on the number of components, a manual breast pump has lesser components than the electric ones and can be managed easily.

Comfort and fit

  • It is said that a manual breast pump tends to mimic the baby’s milk sucking. So it may seem like a manual breast pump is more comfortable to use for. But it’s not just about the fit or the pumping, a mother also needs to feel comfortable to use the pump. With electric pumps, a mother can simply switch on the machine and let it do its work while they can indulge in other works. But with the manual breast pump, a mother needs to actively participate in the pumping which may not be suitable all the time.

Pumping time

  • When you buy a breast pump, you also need to consider the aspect of pumping time. Expressing breast milk via a breast pump is a long process and it requires ample time and effort for a mother. So they have every right to see which pump expresses the milk faster. A manual breast pump expresses the milk in about 45 minutes while the electric breast pump expresses the milk in just 15 minutes. This makes an electric breast pump the right piece to opt for.

Affordability

  • The manual breast pump is priced reasonably well and doesn’t require much of an investment. While the electric ones are priced quite high and are not something that all can buy. Electric breast pumps are suitable for moms who need a regular milk expression and have enough budget to spend.

Portability

  • Manual breast pumps have limited components and smaller in size than an electric breast pump making it a portable option. An electric breast pump is much heavier and is not something that you can carry it around everywhere. Plus the electric one needs the power to use which can be a tough ask. As for a manual breast pump, you can simply use it anywhere and carry it around in your bag with ease.

Ease of sterilization

  • As we discussed above, a breast pump needs to be sterilized and sanitized every time you express the milk and after you’re done with it. This helps ensure that the milk remains free from contaminants and germs. The manual breast pump has a lesser number of components and can easily be washed and sterilized while the electric one needs more rigorous work while cleaning and sterilization.

Bottom Line

We compared the electric and manual breast pumps on different parameters to determine which suits them best. There are a few parameters where the electric breast pump wins it over while a manual breast pump seems the right fit on some parameters. If we were to say, the need and requirement of a mother, which marks the biggest parameter while choosing a breast pump. Both of these breast pumps have their fair share of merits and demerits and we hope a mom can seek the one which suits them the best.

Reply